The Rising Tide of Beverage Industry Litigation: Understanding Key Legal Trends
Reading Time: 5 minutes
As the beverage industry continues to expand, legal disputes have become increasingly common. From craft breweries to major corporations, companies face three primary types of lawsuits: trademark disputes, misleading claims allegations, and distribution rights violations. This surge in litigation reflects the industry’s growing competition and complexity.
Trademark Wars in a Crowded Market
The explosion of craft beverages has created a trademark minefield. With limited options for product names and descriptions, companies frequently clash over branding rights. Notable examples include Lagunitas Brewing’s dispute with Sierra Nevada over IPA packaging design, and Anheuser-Busch InBev’s opposition to She Beverage Co.’s “Queen of Beer” trademark application. It’s important to consider the business implications of legal battles, as litigation costs can be prohibitive regardless of merit. Although these disputes rarely reach trial, companies of all sizes must fiercely defend their trademarks and brand.
Misleading Claims and Consumer Trust
Class action lawsuits targeting allegedly deceptive marketing have become another significant trend. A notable case involved MillerCoors’ Blue Moon brand, which faced allegations of false advertising for marketing itself as “craft beer.” The court’s dismissal of this case could influence future litigation, especially as major brewers continue acquiring craft brands.
Other significant cases include:
- Honest Tea’s ongoing dispute over antioxidant content claims
- PepsiCo’s $9 million settlement regarding Naked Juice’s “all natural” marketing
- The increasing scrutiny of health and ingredient claims across the industry
Distribution Rights: The Battle for Market Access
Distribution agreements have become another battleground, as illustrated by AB InBev’s lawsuit against New Jersey wholesaler Hunterdon over Elysian Brewing Company’s distribution rights. Such disputes often center on fair market value determinations and contract interpretations. The recent Splash Beverage Group claim against KonaRed Corporation over in-house distribution plans demonstrates how these conflicts can affect companies of all sizes.
Digital Marketing: New Frontier for Legal Disputes
The Sazerac versus Jack Daniel’s case highlights emerging challenges in digital marketing. The dispute centered not on traditional trademark usage but on Google advertising practices, where Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Fire allegedly used Sazerac’s “Fireball” trademark in search advertisements. While this particular case was dropped, it signals potential future litigation areas as digital marketing evolves.
Updated Dietary Guidelines and Nutrition Recommendations
The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) are currently drafting new dietary guidelines for 2025-2030, with an anticipated release date by end of 2025. The Interagency Coordinating Committee on the Prevention of Underage Drinking (ICCPUD) within the HHS’ Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration will report on recent research related to alcohol intake and health, and such findings are expected to be incorporated into the new 2025 dietary guidelines.
The longstanding recommendations related to alcohol consumption have been limited to two drinks per day for men and one drink per day for women. However, ICCPUD’s recent research has indicated that no amount of drinking is safe. The current guidelines state “emerging evidence suggests that even drinking within the recommended limits may increase the overall risk of death from various causes, such as from several types of cancer and some forms of cardiovascular disease.”
The study has sparked some controversy with Congress, prompting a bipartisan group of lawmakers to send a letter to the ICCPUD calling for the suspension of the study. Specifically, the lawmakers said that “the secretive process at ICCPUD and the concept of original research on adult alcohol consumption by a committee tasked with preventing underage drinking, jeopardizes the credibility of ICCPUD and its ability to continue its primary role of helping the nation prevent underage drinking… We question why ICCPUD would choose to redirect limited resources away from its core responsibilities that are meant to fund a national media campaign as well as offer federal grants to community coalitions and the medical community.”
The alcohol beverage industry is waiting with bated breath to review and adapt to the new guidelines. However, it would be premature to react to such guidelines before they become final. Regardless of the new guidelines, the alcohol beverage industry will respond in the best interest of the public and ensure compliance, whatever that may entail. The alcohol beverage industry is one of the most highly regulated industries in the United States and the world. The industry is well equipped to navigate new guidelines and regulations that may come from lawmakers and agencies, which will most likely include new labels, disclaimers, and marketing materials.
Impact on Industry Strategy
For beverage companies, these legal trends necessitate careful strategic planning:
- Brand Protection: Companies must conduct thorough trademark searches and maintain robust protection strategies.
- Marketing Claims: Labels and promotional materials require careful review to prevent misleading claim allegations, especially in light of the anticipated 2025 dietary guidelines.
- Distribution Agreements: Clear contract terms and fair market value provisions are essential.
- Digital Marketing: Companies need comprehensive policies governing online advertising practices.
Looking Forward
The beverage industry’s legal landscape continues evolving with market saturation and technological advancement. While major companies may have deeper pockets for litigation, success often depends on strategic choices rather than size alone. As Christopherson notes, “There are only so many great names out there… companies really do have to expect to be involved in this sort of dispute at some point in their existence.”
For new entrants and established players alike, understanding these legal trends is crucial for long-term success. Proactive legal strategies and careful brand management can help companies navigate this increasingly complex landscape while minimizing costly disputes. Contact us today!